Wednesday, August 29, 2007

WALKING AWAY FROM MURDER

The NY Times reports that there's a good chance that no one will be sent to prison for murdering civilians at Haditha.


Since May, charges against two infantrymen and a Marine officer have been dismissed, and dismissal has been recommended for murder charges against a third infantryman.

The presiding officer, Lt. Col. Paul J. Ware, is the same Marine lawyer who conducted hearings for Justin L. Sharratt and Stephen B. Tatum, two other lance corporals accused of killing a total of five Iraqis in three homes in Haditha.

Colonel Ware later recommended dismissing the charges against those two men, and he has said the killings should be viewed in the context of combat against an enemy that ruthlessly employs civilians as cover. He warned that murder charges against marines could harm the morale of troops still in Iraq.

General Mattis’s statements expressing sympathy for the plight of other enlisted marines whom he cleared of wrongdoing in Haditha may indicate his willingness to see Sergeant Wuterich’s case in a similar light.



This brought to mind the acquittal of Lt. Pantano, the man who emptied 2 clips into two unarmed Iraqi men and the minor punishment Cpl. Thomas received for his role in killing an innocent Iraqi. There are many accounts that back up the claim that our military thinks Iraqi lives are cheap and even Prime Minister Maliki has spoken out against our murderous negligence. As I wrote earlier, many seem to have the attitude that Cpl. Lopezromo stated: "Marines consider all Iraqi men part of the insurgency."

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

The military has the right idea with these tribunals.

Imagine if Enron, Worldcom, Imclone, and the like had also been allowed to investigate their own scandals and rule with such finality.

Anonymous said...

The evidence clearly shows that a great miscarriage of justice has been imposed on a group of some of the bravest and finest of Americans — the men of the Kilo Company, 3rd Battalion, 1st Marine Regiment.

Intelligence gathered by Marine S2 officers in advance of the events of Nov. 19th, 2005, revealed that it was known that an insurgent ambush was planned for the day.
Although exact details of the planned ambush were not known, some important details were revealed — most importantly, that some 20 insurgents would take part, and a white car would play an important role in the ambush.
The intelligence was made available to the officers and men of Kilo Company including Sgt. Frank Wuterich who has been charged with, among other things, murdering the occupants of a white car that came on the scene following the IED explosion that killed one Marine and seriously wounded another. The evidence will show that Wuterich acted appropriately when he shot the passengers of the vehicle.
Although the media continues to report that 24 innocent civilians were killed that day, the S2's testimony shows that eight of the dead, including four of the five occupants in the white car killed by Wuterich, were known insurgents and the dead civilians therefore numbered 16, not 24.
The insurgents whose communications were intercepted and which revealed the planned ambush were the same two men who were the sources of the fallacious and dishonest Time magazine story, which was the source of the accusations against the Marines.

Heh, I found that at http://archive.newsmax.com/archives/...4/130557.shtml
Seems like the Marine might have acted appropriately..sorta